In the frozen heart of a Chicago winter, two teenage sisters left a movie theater and vanished into the night. What followed was one of the most haunting and baffling mysteries in Illinois history.
More than six decades later, the Grimes sisters case remains unsolved. No arrests. No clear motive. Just two bodies, a string of bizarre sightings, and a city that still whispers their names.
This is not folklore. This is not urban legend. This is true crime at its most chilling. In this article, we explore the facts, the theories, and the unanswered questions surrounding the 1956 disappearance and murder of Barbara and Patricia Grimes—a case that still freezes the blood of anyone who reads it.
The Disappearance
On the night of December 28, 1956, Barbara (15) and Patricia Grimes (13) left their South Side Chicago home to see the Elvis Presley film Love Me Tender at the Brighton Theater. They were expected home before midnight.
They never returned.
At first, their mother, Loretta, thought they had missed the bus. But by morning, panic set in. She contacted police, and the search began.
The Grimes sisters were well-behaved and close. They had no reason to run away. The community mobilized. Flyers were printed. The media latched on. Even Elvis Presley himself issued a statement asking the girls to come home.
But no one knew where they had gone—or why.
The Investigation Begins
Police scoured the neighborhood and interviewed hundreds of people. Tips poured in. Over 300,000 people were questioned or investigated. Some witnesses claimed to have seen the girls after their disappearance, at bus stops, diners, even out of town.
One of the most credible sightings came from a friend who claimed to have seen the girls in a car with an unknown man. Another said they saw them at a Chicago-area restaurant looking disoriented. But none of these leads produced concrete results.
Theories ranged from kidnapping to voluntary disappearance. Some speculated that the girls had run away to Nashville to meet Elvis. But their bodies told a different story.
The Gruesome Discovery
On January 22, 1957, nearly a month after their disappearance, the nude bodies of Barbara and Patricia were discovered by a passing motorist on German Church Road in Willow Springs, about 25 miles from their home.
Their bodies were lying in a ditch, partially obscured by snow. The autopsy revealed signs of sexual abuse and bruising, but the cause of death could not be determined. One sister had what appeared to be puncture wounds on her chest. The other had multiple abrasions.
The coroner eventually ruled the cause of death as secondary shock due to exposure, though this was controversial even at the time.
One chilling detail: their bodies showed signs of having been refrigerated or kept cold for some time before being dumped.
This wasn’t a spontaneous act of violence. It was calculated.
The Main Suspect: Benny Bedwell
Soon after the discovery, police arrested Benny Bedwell, a 21-year-old drifter from Tennessee who resembled Elvis Presley. He worked at a local diner and had been seen with two girls resembling the Grimes sisters.
Bedwell eventually confessed to the crime, claiming he and an accomplice had picked the girls up, fed them, and later killed them after they refused sexual advances.
But problems emerged. His timeline didn’t match. His confession had inconsistencies. And the autopsy did not support the cause of death he described.
Bedwell later recanted. Police dropped charges. The investigation lost momentum.
Theories and Speculation
1. Organized Crime?
Some theorists believe the girls may have witnessed something they shouldn’t have, or were taken by a local figure with power and influence. The lack of physical evidence and mishandled investigation suggest a possible cover-up.
2. Serial Killer Link?
Some researchers believe the Grimes sisters were early victims of an unknown serial killer who operated in Illinois in the 1950s and 60s. Several other cases—girls around the same age, with similar causes of death—remain unsolved.
3. Law Enforcement Involvement?
One anonymous tip claimed that a local cop had harassed one of the sisters shortly before their disappearance. Nothing came of the lead, but suspicion lingered, especially since key case files were lost or destroyed over time.
The Aftermath
The case broke Loretta Grimes emotionally and physically. She dedicated years of her life to finding justice for her daughters. She passed away in 1989, still without answers.
In 2013, retired cop Ray Johnson began re-investigating the case using modern forensic techniques and witness statements. He uncovered new leads and even named a possible suspect—someone who had previously been overlooked.
But the case remains officially open, and officially cold.
The Legacy
The Grimes sisters’ murders forever changed the way Chicago investigated missing children. The city created a special task force to handle disappearances. The case also inspired stories, songs, and folklore. For many, it was the moment when innocence died in Chicago.
Even today, the phrase “Grimes sisters cold case” ranks high in search volume across Illinois and true crime forums nationwide. People are still drawn to the mystery, the tragedy, and the failure to bring a killer to justice.
The Grimes sisters’ case remains one of the most haunting unsolved murders in American history. What happened on that snowy December night? Who took two teenage girls from a movie theater and left their bodies in a ditch? And why has no one ever paid for this crime?
Until those answers come, this case remains a wound in the soul of Chicago—and a permanent part of the Sinister Archive.
Solve your own case here.
For more cases like this, stay with us at SinisterArchive.com, where the truth is darker than the legend.